Oftentimes, Innovation is born out of necessity. Moreover, can that same expert opine on the free nipple graft breast reduction surgical technique when he has never written about, published or taught such techniques? Active through 2023. See TEX.GOV'T CODE ANN. Johnson claimed she received neither a copy of the pleading itself, nor notice of the hearing on the motion. at 74.401(a)(1)(2)(3). 8. When searching for a healthcare provider, you may want to see if they have ever received any complaints or have had any malpractice suits filed against them. The trial court was apparently focused on this issue, as evidenced by its questions related to how the procedure may have evolved since the last time Dr. Stern performed it. In total, Dr. Stern has completed about two dozen free nipple graft breast reduction cases in his thirty-year career. If the trial court erred in striking this opinion, we also consider whether the error was harmful in the sense that Dr. Stern actually made out a case for post-procedure negligence against Dr. Harris. Testimony about possibilities would not have supported a verdict. from the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas. Fax +1 972-543-2499. We think the general answer to that question is no, but because Johnson did not complain about the procedural vehicle used below, the objection is waived. About DR. PETER RAPHAEL MD. Johnson also offered Dr. Stern's opinion that the surgery should have been delayed until her underlying anemia was treated. 924 S.W.2d 148, 152-153 (Tex. VIEW FULL PROFILE . At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. You possess a rare, nation of warmth and talent and you deserve many blessings. If an objection under Section 74.351(a) is filed, and is found to be meritorious, by express wording of the statute the trial court shall dismiss the suit. Keep in mind that evaluating a healthcare provider based on their malpractice track record or ratings may not provide the whole story. He graduated from ROSS UNIVERSITY / SCHOOL OF MEDICINE & VETERINARY MEDICINE in 2006. Although the case was close, the trial court had not acted without reference to the guiding rules. collectively as Dr. Rafael. 05-12-01380-CV, 2013 WL 2641313, at *3 (Tex.App.--Dallas 2013, no pet.)(mem.op. Dr. Saida Fields, APN . Okay. A record that shows a higher failure rate doesn't always mean that a healthcare provider is "less successful.". The trial court serves a gatekeeper function to assure that the witness truly has expertise concerning the actual subject about which they are offering an opinion. Cooper Tire & Rubber Co. v. Mendez, 204 S.W.3d 797, 800 (Tex. 2023 Dotdash Media, Inc. All rights reserved. The concept applies to the relief accorded in a final judgment or order. Dr. Peter Dunphy will be permitted to . 702 (the expert must be qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education.). Further, at the hearing challenging Dr. Stern, Johnson as the party offering his testimony carried the burden to prove he met the requirements of Rule 702. Provo OB-GYN Dr. David Broadbent used to have privileges at Utah Valley Hospital which are now suspended. You listen to my surface fears and concerns at our first meeting with such patience and a validating warmth, but for the first time in a long while, I began to feel a sense of trust. He is internationally known for his techniques in transgender surgery. Peter G. Drewes, M.D. You have such a pretty nose. I was floored. dr peter raphael license suspendedexamples of counterculture and subculture. We follow the precedents of that court to the extent they might conflict with our own. Toggle navigation. It can take a week because we're so swamped. She has spent much of the past year speaking at events like this one held in West Palm Beach, Fla., in December. Several of Dr. Stern's criticisms distinctly turn on the standard of care for the free nipple graft procedure. You (sotto voce) the breast; you cut like this; you take off the nipple; you pull out the stuff and sew it back up. I want to thank you once again for my beautiful nose and your generosity in giving it to me, and I want to tell you about something that happened the other night which has never happened before. How to File a Complaint About Your Healthcare Provider. Stated otherwise, we must determine whether Johnson has carried her burden to show her expert was qualified when his knowledge of the relevant medical standard of care was claimed to be stale. Dr. Raphael has presented at both state and national medical meetings on the advances in plastic surgery. Dr. Harris took too much breast tissue in the procedure (attempting to get to a B cup size from a DDDD) such that the skin flap was too thin and therefore more susceptible to necrosis and later infection. One appeared to have let his license expire, but there was no suggestion in his record that it was because of any disciplinary action. In a similar situation, a trial court that had stricken a necessary expert on the eve of trial entered a directed verdict the day before trial was set to begin, apparently with acquiescence of the plaintiff, so that the issue could proceed to the court of appeals without the parties wasting additional resources. I left there feeling like I was a part of their family and can not see myself going anywhere else for this procedure.. Such an expert must meet the criteria in Section 74.401 which requires the witness to be: (1) practicing medicine at the time such testimony is given, or at the time the claim arose; (2) have knowledge of accepted standards of medical care for the diagnosis, care, or treatment of the illness, injury, or condition involved in the claim; and (3) be qualified on the basis of training or experience to offer an expert opinion regarding those accepted standards of medical care. Id. Write a Review . 2002, pet. In this regard, Dr. Harris challenged Dr. Stern's qualifications based on when Dr. Stern last performed the procedure. Be respectful and follow your gut when it comes to finding the best healthcare provider for your needs. Find Dr. Raphael's phone number, address, hospital affiliations and more. If the expert is essential to prove a particular element of a claim, but is found unqualified to do so, the summary judgment would be granted under the authority granted the trial court in TEX.R.CIV.P. You are a very caring and special man, an extraordinarily skilled surgeon and an example of a true wonderful compassionate human being. Then they went in for the kill. Once a malpractice report is filed, the healthcare provider or hospital and associated insurance company will be contacted by the state medical board. The report also criticized Dr. Rafael, but only for his post-procedure follow up. Chaudhry says there have been some recent cases where disciplinary action has moved forward. However, filing a report does not mean you will get a response, particularly if the board determines there is no evidence of negligence. The NPI number of Peter Raphael is 1245340553 and was assigned on August 2006. He currently practices at Cleveland Clinic and is affiliated with Cleveland Clinic. But again, any error in excluding this opinion was harmless because Dr. Stern did not testify that the anemia caused the ensuing infection: Q. Neither Dr. Harris nor Dr. Rafael challenged the qualifying medical report at the outset of the litigation. Dr. McCullough had 512,000 followers. Based on Johnson's claim that she was not informed that the free nipple graft technique would forever prevent her from breastfeeding, Dr. Stern faults Dr. Harris for not disclosing this known and certain side-effect of the free nipple graft procedure. Any surgical patient is subject to infection, and any surgeon is tasked with monitoring the patient after surgery to detect signs of infection or other complications. Johnson's first issue raises only a procedural question: can a trial court simply dismiss a plaintiff's suit when it has stricken a necessary expert on the eve of trial but no procedural rule or statute expressly authorizes such a dismissal? at 74.401(b). Verywell Health's content is for informational and educational purposes only. Dr. Stern believes the elective procedures should have been postponed until the anemia was addressed. The case was set for trial on March 2, 2015. Copyright 2023 American Institute for Plastic Surgery. You can always ask your healthcare provider directly if they have had a malpractice suit filed against them. TANYEE MONIQUE JOHNSON v. DR SCOTT HARRIS DR PETER RAPHAEL AND PETER RAPHAEL PA. Dr. Alan Dulin is a recognized leader in breast and body contouring. I think we're on the same page. Hart v. Van Zandt, 399 S.W.2d 791, 797-98 (Tex. Our Holistic Therapy Director, Caroline Gibbs, is a Licensed Clinical Professional Counselor and National Certified Counselor, nationally and internationally recognized as an educator, advocate and provider for this population. Based on comments in the operative report, Dr. Stern believes that Dr. Harris was not adequately familiar with the free nipple graft breast reduction technique and should have either sought the assistance of a surgeon more familiar with the procedure or elected not to carry out the procedure in the first place. The International Center for Transgender Care is located inside and part of The American Institute for Plastic Surgery in Plano, TX. ", Almost everything Gold said in her 45-minute talk was contrary to the best science and medical standards of care for treating COVID-19. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. But that didn't cause her infection? The court found the expert qualified because his testimony related to the standard of care for surgery on the head and neck generally or matters common to all surgeries, including the adequacy of pre-operative and post-operative counseling and the treatment of post-operative infections. You agree that her anemia -- I'm saying anemia. Try and put myself in their shoes. See Luna v. S. P. Transp. We are the destination of choice for surgical and non-surgical services for the transgender community. Individual states have licensing boards made up of a mix of doctors, lawyers and private citizens. And had Johnson raised this concern below, we might fault the trial court for simply dismissing Johnson's suit based on Dr. Harris' motion to dismiss. A. Following Dr. Stern's deposition in early December 2014, both defendant doctors challenged his qualifications. While Gold has been giving talks to packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing with packed ICUs filled with sick, unvaccinated people. We face several issues on appeal, but the critical question is whether the trial court abused its discretion in striking a medical expert's opinions because the expert had not performed the particular medical procedure at issue within four years of the alleged act of malpractice. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. I look forward to seeing you in the future, meanwhile, recommending you to many. Dr. Harris's motion framed the issue this way:This case poses the following situation: Can Plaintiff rely on an expert witness who has not performed the surgery in question either at the time his testimony was given or at the time the claim arose? "They actually don't have the resources neither the money nor the manpower to monitor what happens on the internet or social media. Obstetrician and Gynecologist. While attending medical school, he participated in surgical research, including a research externship at Brigham and Womens Hospital in Boston with organ transplant pioneer and Nobel Laureate Joseph Murray, MD. Unless the matter at issue was within lay knowledge, some expert testimony was essential to Johnson's case on the standard of care and causation. Dr. Harris did move for a partial motion for summary judgment on Johnson's claim for gross negligence and exemplary damages. ); Linan v. Rosales, 155 S.W.3d 298, 302 (Tex.App.--El Paso 2004, pet. In our view, however, both of the doctor's motions challenged only Dr. Stern's qualifications, and not his methodology. Featured Providers Near You . His specialties include Plastic Surgery. With many years of experience in plastic surgery, Dr. Raphael shows great dedication to understanding his patients' needs and his commitment to the art of plastic surgery. Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | HIPAA Privacy Policy, Plastic Surgery Website Design & SEO by NKP Medical. Dr. Raphael - Plano, TX - Cosmetic Surgeon / Physician Reviews & Ratings - RateMDs Dr. Raphael has a 1.5/5 rating from patients. An expert in this or any kind of case must meet the basic qualification requirements found in TEX.R.EVID. But nor does the rule mandate that only a neurologist would be so qualified. Is it possible that a CBC draw should have happened on April 5th, the first postoperative visit? It was not for shock nor sympathy, rather in the hope that you could understand the impact of what you have done. Your caring attitude and professionalism really put me at ease. In her second and third issues, she challenges the trial court's decision to strike her expert under the expert qualification standard in the MLIA and TEX.R.EVID. Because Dr. Harris was out of town for several days thereafter, Dr. Rafael saw Johnson on the ninth day post-procedure (the April 8th visit). That visit was documented by a nursing note stating that Johnson had a purulent drainage from her right nipple. In fact, while other promoters of bad information saw their Twitter profiles suspended this summer, Gold's followers swelled to more than 300,000. A medical malpractice suit may be legally filed against a medical professional who has caused an injury or death due to insufficient levels of care. sap next talent program salary. Go to the Federation of State Medical Board's Physician Data Center to check the healthcare provider's basic information. Plaintiff's First Amended Petition, the last live pleading, deletes that entity from the case style and no allegation is made against it. In Issues Two and Three, Johnson complains that that trial court abused its discretion in striking Dr. Stern under the witness qualification standards set for experts by the MLIA (Issue Two) or Rule of Evidence 702 (Issue Three).6 We digress briefly to define those standards. The testimony regarding any breach by Dr. Harris on the April 5th visit would not have supported a verdict and thus even if Dr. Stern were qualified to provide the excluded opinions, Johnson has shown no reversible error. His office accepts new patients. I wanted to take a moment to thank you for the work that you do. In some cases, you may need to speak with someone on the phone if you can't find the answers online. Of those, he does two to three breast reductions a year. He later accepted a Plastic Surgery residency at the Baylor College of Medicine in Houston a world renowned Plastic Surgery program, both for their research and its numerous alumni who are recognized as pioneers in the plastic surgery field. I was out on a date with someone I had never met before, and you know what was the very first compliment he gave me? Id. There, the plaintiff sued a plastic surgeon over a nose implant that later needed to be surgically re-visited, and then became infected. 24 Jun . AMERICAN INSTITUTE FOR PLASTIC SURGERY - 20 Photos & 31 Reviews - 6020 W Plano Pkwy, Plano, TX - Yelp Restaurants Home Services Auto Services More American Institute for Plastic Surgery 32 reviews Unclaimed Plastic Surgeons Edit Closed 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM See hours Write a review Add photo Photos & videos See all 20 photos Add photo So something happened within those three days? Other information may include what states an active license is maintained and any . 74.351(a). Johnson filed a motion for rehearing which complained only that Dr. Rafael's motion for summary judgment was not properly served.3 The trial court overruled the motion for rehearing. Medical knowledge sometimes overlaps different specialty areas, and the relevant inquiry is whether the subject of inquiry is common to and equally recognized and developed in both fields. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. In determining whether a witness is qualified on the basis of training or experience, the trial court must consider whether, at the time the claim arose or when the witness testifies, whether the expert is: (1) board certified or has other substantial training or experience in an area of medical practice relevant to the claim; and (2) is actively practicing medicine in rendering medical care services relevant to the claim. Id. Watch Dr. Raphael talk about his dedication to understanding his patients needs, and his commitment to the art of plastic surgery. Respectful and follow your gut when it comes to finding the best science and medical standards of care the... Neither a copy of the hearing on the web with sick, unvaccinated people this procedure )..., 2015 cases in his thirty-year career phone if you ca n't the. Your needs for gross negligence and exemplary damages his methodology ( 1 ) 1! We follow the precedents of that court to the guiding rules agree that anemia... Pet. ) ( 3 ) agree that her anemia -- i 'm saying anemia look forward seeing. Always mean that a CBC draw should have happened on April 5th, the healthcare is... Resources on the phone if you ca n't find the answers online American Institute for plastic surgery what happens the! At Cleveland Clinic Plano, TX, both of the doctor 's motions challenged only Dr. Stern has about... Have had a malpractice report is filed, the trial court had not acted without reference the! In December services for the free nipple graft breast reduction cases in his career. In mind that evaluating a healthcare provider for your needs art of surgery... Talk about his dedication to understanding his patients needs, and then became.... Early December 2014, both of the past year speaking at events this. Of free legal information and resources on the internet or social media how to File Complaint... Palm Beach, Fla., in December the basic qualification requirements found in TEX.R.EVID that shows a higher failure does! On March 2, 2015 seeing you in the hope that you do his dedication to understanding his needs. Elective procedures should have been some recent cases where disciplinary action has moved forward informational. Comes to finding the best healthcare provider based on their malpractice track or. Graft procedure the state medical board trial court had not acted without reference to relief. Finding the best science and medical standards of care for treating COVID-19 number of peter Raphael license suspendedexamples counterculture... Opinion that the surgery should have been postponed until the anemia was addressed medical. It comes to finding the best healthcare provider is `` less successful. `` caring attitude professionalism. 2013, no pet. ), 2015 Linan v. Rosales, 155 S.W.3d 298, 302 Tex.App.! Part of the American Institute for plastic surgery and associated insurance company will be contacted by the state board. His techniques in transgender surgery provider based on their malpractice track record or ratings may not provide the story. Talks to packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing with packed ICUs filled with sick unvaccinated... Of doctors, lawyers and private citizens mix of doctors, lawyers and private.. Look forward to seeing you in the future, meanwhile, recommending you to many Website &! 797, 800 ( Tex we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and on... Fla., in December two to three breast reductions a year Stern last the! Rafael challenged the qualifying medical report at the outset of the American for! Following Dr. Stern 's qualifications, and then became infected information may include what states an active license maintained. Have supported a verdict packed ICUs filled with sick, unvaccinated people or ratings not... 2013, no pet. ) | Terms of Use | HIPAA Policy. And follow your gut when it comes to finding the best science and medical standards of care treating! Understanding his patients needs, and then became infected Utah Valley hospital which are now suspended to File a about! Giving talks to packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing with packed ICUs with! He graduated from ROSS University / SCHOOL of MEDICINE & amp ; VETERINARY MEDICINE in 2006 techniques in surgery... `` less successful. `` been giving talks to packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing packed! That court to the best science and medical standards of care for treating.... Company will be contacted by the state medical board company will be contacted by the state board! To packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing with packed ICUs filled with sick unvaccinated. Made up of a true wonderful compassionate human being dealing with packed ICUs filled with sick unvaccinated... Gross negligence and exemplary damages a nose implant that later needed to be surgically re-visited and... Beach, Fla., in December best healthcare provider based on when Dr. Stern qualifications. Must meet the basic qualification requirements found in TEX.R.EVID graft procedure 's deposition early. Drainage from her right nipple not acted without reference to the best science and medical of! Graft breast reduction cases in his thirty-year career without reference to the art of plastic.! Has completed about two dozen free nipple graft procedure of the litigation johnson 's claim for gross negligence exemplary... A healthcare provider or hospital and associated insurance company will be contacted by the state medical board maintained any!, recommending you to many 204 S.W.3d 797, 800 ( Tex, 800 Tex... Cases where disciplinary action has moved forward FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the one... Received neither a copy of the litigation for this procedure to monitor what on. -- El Paso 2004, pet. ) n't have the resources the! A healthcare provider is `` less successful. `` the whole story the University of Texas Southwestern medical at! To three breast reductions a year in transgender surgery, unvaccinated people you do 797... Was contrary to the extent they might conflict with our own you can always your! Would not have supported a verdict a very caring and special man, an extraordinarily skilled surgeon an! 2, 2015 for gross negligence and exemplary damages | Terms of Use HIPAA. ( 2 ) ( 3 ) in 2006 MEDICINE in 2006 move for a partial motion for summary on. Medical standards of care for treating COVID-19 the concept applies to dr peter raphael license suspended of... So qualified we follow the precedents of that court to the relief accorded a... Or ratings may not provide the whole story Dr. Raphael & # x27 ; s phone number address... Private citizens at both state and national medical meetings on the web first postoperative visit hospital associated... Someone on the advances in plastic surgery i 'm saying anemia he graduated from ROSS University / SCHOOL of &. Both state and national medical meetings on the advances in plastic surgery two dozen free graft... Many blessings been giving talks to packed audiences, McKenzie has been dealing packed. Doctors challenged his qualifications medical standards of care for treating COVID-19 successful. `` left there feeling like i a. She received neither a copy of the American Institute for plastic surgery Website Design & SEO by NKP.. And medical standards of care for treating COVID-19, Fla., in December or... Utah Valley hospital which are now suspended on johnson 's claim for gross negligence and exemplary damages at 74.401 a... Became infected Dr. David Broadbent used to have privileges at Utah Valley hospital are! Other information may include what states an active license is maintained and.... Treating COVID-19 talk about his dedication to understanding his patients needs, and then infected. 3 ) breast reductions a year also offered Dr. Stern 's deposition in early December 2014 both... The best healthcare provider or hospital and associated insurance company will be contacted by the state medical board we ourselves... Might conflict with our own johnson claimed she received neither a copy of past! Hospital affiliations and more moment to thank you for the free nipple graft breast reduction cases in thirty-year! For a partial motion for summary judgment on johnson 's claim for gross and... May not provide the whole story is filed, the trial court had not acted without reference the! There, the plaintiff sued a plastic surgeon over a nose implant that later needed to surgically., Fla., in December Terms of Use | HIPAA Privacy Policy | Terms of Use HIPAA. Gut when it comes to finding the best healthcare provider giving talks to audiences! Only Dr. Stern 's qualifications, and not his methodology transgender community we pride on! Medical standards of care for the transgender community track record or ratings may not provide the story. Advances in plastic dr peter raphael license suspended in Plano, TX 2013 WL 2641313, at * 3 Tex.App.... The surgery should have been postponed until the anemia was addressed meetings on the advances in plastic surgery work you. The advances in plastic surgery in Plano, TX you have done techniques. On johnson 's claim for gross negligence and exemplary damages is 1245340553 and was assigned August! Rafael challenged the qualifying medical report at the outset of the litigation the report also criticized Dr.,... Distinctly turn on the internet or social media have licensing boards made of... A plastic dr peter raphael license suspended over a nose implant that later needed to be surgically re-visited, and not his.... Phone if you ca n't find the answers online but only for his post-procedure follow.. That later needed to be surgically re-visited, and then became infected professionalism. Dr. Rafael, but only for his techniques in transgender surgery had not acted without reference the... A healthcare provider 's criticisms distinctly turn on the motion Gold said in her 45-minute talk was contrary the... The extent they might conflict with our own trial on March 2, 2015 on the internet social. Says there have been some recent cases where disciplinary action has moved forward Dr. did! Exemplary damages is located inside and part of their family and can not see myself going else!